Comments for sursumcorda.salemsattic.com/post/temple-grandin

Comment #2152

2010-11-22T12:57:30Z

it is weird that they don't take into consideration strong vs. slight. There are a couple questions which I debated on, but I think there were a couple in both directions, so the score would probably stay around the same.

I'm also surprised at the result,p since I can see various autistic tendencies in myself.

There was a research summary in CMU's newspaper once that showed various types of college majors/people on an austism spectrum. The progression was something like:

drama, english, ..., women, men, ..., female engineers, male engineers, high functioning Asbergers, ..., low functioning autistics.

That progression made sense to me.

As for introverts vs. extroverts, I used to think extroverts meant outgoing, loud, etc. but then I came across the Meyers-Briggs definition, which I think is a better, more useful definition. Where that definition (or at least the one I now use that I think came from them) is that an extrovert gains energy by spending time with people and an introvert gains energy by being by himself. I am the most extroverted person I've ever met, by that definition.

Comment #2151

2010-11-03T21:18:06Z

I had the same difficulty as DSTB's D, for the same reason. Plenty of the situations could have gone either way, depending on what the question was referring to and the exemplary experience that first came to mind. (Asking the same thing twice doesn't improve the questionnaire, except perhaps for indecisive amnesiacs.)

The introvert / extrovert distinction is another and I think separate issue. Is an extrovert an outgoing person? Then I am no extrovert, though I have worked at strengthening that social muscle. Is an extrovert a person who enjoys and gets energized by social activities? Then I might be an extrovert - more so than my wife, even though initial impressions might suggest otherwise. Even so, I enjoy doing things on my own - another conundrum akin to the social activity questions. Do I prefer a solo job to a group project? Generally yes, because it's easier to manage and I pull my own weight and nothing but. Do I prefer a solo activity over a social activity? Probably usually not.

Comment #2150

2010-11-03T15:20:43Z

I know the feeling! I wish we could accept, respect, and even appreciate our personality differences without a scientific "explanation" for them, but it does seem to help. "I am not alone" is a powerful force, too.

Comment #2149

2010-11-03T14:05:23Z

You can leave it. I began to suspect this about a year ago and it's been quite liberating actually - to know that I am not "stupid," I just have an identified difficulty with some things.

Comment #2148

2010-11-03T09:37:32Z

19 - must mean I am already a retired geek.

Comment #2147

2010-11-03T00:25:30Z

I think it's somehow related to the fact that you're the only golfer in the family. :)

Comment #2146

2010-11-03T00:20:40Z

Based on your theory does my 11 mean I am below average? I found it hard to answer the social / party questions. I enjoy social chit chat and parties if I know everyone, but stick me in a room where I don't know anyone and it is not enjoyable.

Comment #2145

2010-11-02T15:24:56Z

I think it was a perfectly appropriate and interesting comment, but if you'd like I'll excise it. I don't want my wonderful comment-writers to be uncomfortable and think about not writing. :)

Comment #2144

2010-11-02T14:40:16Z

You know, I rattled off that answer, hit send and then thought "No, that's not an appropriate response, it's too personal and sounds a bit like bragging," so tried to stop the send. Guess I both failed to stop the send and rather re-inforced the diagnosis. The thing is, I would have answered more questions as "strongly" rather than "slightly" but (I thought) I have learned *some* socially acceptable behaviour over the years.

Comment #2143

2010-11-02T13:50:27Z

I'm curious, though. The control group average was 16.4, why are we all scoring above 20? (Naturally, all my readers are above average.)

It seems that the test is weighted so that engineering types and introverts score high. Thus I'm really curious as to where Jon falls, he being an extrovert engineer.

Comment #2142

2010-11-02T13:38:55Z

Apparently there was no difference between strongly and slightly. Seems strange, and is one reason I never trust this kind of questionnaire/survey. Why waste people's time with that distinction if you're not going to use it?

Comment #2141

2010-11-02T12:42:05Z

Was there no difference in grading whether you strongly or slightly agreed/disagreed?

Comment #2140

2010-11-02T02:47:59Z

I'm impressed, Katie. There are a lot of geeks here, and you out-geeked us all.

Comment #2139

2010-11-02T02:37:26Z

Oh, lord.

That explains a lot.

Comment #2138

2010-11-01T23:02:23Z

But I could take it again and get a 25 or 27 if I wanted to (or lower, depending on what I felt like proving). Fortunately, knowing that I could is good enough so there's no point in actually doing so.

Comment #2137

2010-11-01T21:22:38Z

In a few years you may be down to my 25. :)

Comment #2136

2010-11-01T20:14:03Z

If it makes you feel any better, I scored 27 - though I think ten years ago I would have scored even higher.